Homemade Cookies

Pick a half dozen of a favorite or build a tray with flavors for everyone.

Start With The Classics

Chocolate Chip Wish Cookies have semisweet chunks and soft centers. Stardust Sugar Cookies are vanilla stars, and Cinnamon Puff Snickerdoodles bring cinnamon sugar to the tray.

Add A Surprise Flavor

Try Raspberry Dusk for a darker chocolate cookie with fruit or Cranberry Comet for an oatmeal cookie with cranberries and orange. Brown Butter Pecan Charms add a toasted, nutty option.

See The Menu

Count By The Half Dozen

Martha lists cookies in sets of six. Work out how many flavors and sets you want instead of trying to count individual cookies across the whole table.

Set Out A Mixed Tray

Keep each flavor in its own group so guests can tell the cookies apart. If ingredient questions matter for your guests, ask Martha’s team before choosing or serving the assortment.

Find Your Cookie Match

Search the live menu for chocolate, cinnamon, fruit, or pecan. Molly can help you find options, and the bakery can answer questions about a date or a larger order.

Back To The Bakery Guide ↗